1Research question and scope
The stated purpose is to understand which nickel lattice characteristics could support hydrogen organization and the collective response proposed for LENR. The materials question addressed here is which sites bind hydrogen, and how does filling those sites change the surrounding metal? The design value lies in connecting those results to the structure, hydrogen population and host state required by that purpose.
The first calculation set, called campaign 1 in the data archive, compares six H sites, two entry paths and three imposed strains on Ni(111), a close-packed nickel surface. Campaign 2 tests sensitivity to the magnetic state, a surface vacancy and H pairs. Campaign 3 examines selected hydrogen-covered surfaces and a bulk vacancy with one to six H atoms around it. We call these neighboring H atoms a vacancy shell; its occupancy is the number of H atoms present.
The study calculates structures, energies, magnetic moments and forces. Its interpretation concerns a proposed mechanism involving collective modes, in which atoms move together, and coherence, in which motions or fields maintain a phase relationship over space and time. These dynamics and an LENR response are not calculated here. Sections 11–13 explain what the existing results contribute to that mechanism and where the design conclusions stop.
1aMeaning for the stated lattice objective
A buried vacancy provides a defined local hydrogen arrangement. All six sampled H additions bind favorably around the bulk vacancy. The final shell has approximately octahedral symmetry and a nearest H–H spacing of 2.443 Å. The useful feature is several H atoms sharing a defect environment within nickel. Six is the largest tested occupancy, not an established capacity limit.
Hydrogen organization in the interior has a different energetic basis from surface loading. On clean Ni(111), the preferred surface site is 0.697 eV below the subsurface octahedral site. Stretching the surface by 2% leaves a 0.663 eV gap. Thus surface hydrogen inventory and an energetically supported interior arrangement are distinct material characteristics. The sampled buried vacancy supplies the latter.
Vacancy abundance and filling determine different parts of the hydrogen inventory. Favorable binding describes H at an existing vacancy; the formation energy describes the cost of producing that vacancy. The equilibrium model also permits partial filling, with a mean of about 2.33 H per vacancy at 500 K and 1 bar. A lattice with fewer filled vacancies contains fewer copies of the local arrangement, even if total hydrogen uptake is similar.
Filling changes the local Ni state as well as the number of H atoms. The nearest calculated Ni moments decrease, and the mean force on the fixed Ni changes direction between two and three H. For a mechanism involving the metal's electronic or elastic response, these are meaningful changes in the environment of the hydrogen. The current evidence supports an occupancy-dependent local H/Ni state; it does not establish that separate vacancy shells form a coherent domain or increase LENR activity.
2Methods and numerical checks
Three types of quantity are kept separate throughout: the energy of putting H at a site, the barrier for moving between sites, and the probability of occupying a site at a specified temperature and pressure. An energetically favorable site can still be difficult to reach; a migration barrier alone does not give its equilibrium population.
Density-functional theory (DFT) approximates the electronic energy and forces for a chosen atomic structure. We use GPAW with the PBE exchange-correlation approximation and PAW treatment of core electrons, a 500 eV plane-wave cutoff and spin polarization for ferromagnetic nickel. The cell is a four-layer 2×2 Ni(111) slab (16 Ni atoms, one H, 0.25 monolayer or ML—one H per four surface Ni atoms); an asymmetric-slab dipole correction is applied. Relaxations and paths use a 3×3×1 k-point mesh; final quoted site energies use 4×4×1. This model can compare specified sites and paths, not calculate an alloy's bulk solubility.
Independent code comparison (campaign 2). The fcc and octa adsorption energies, fixed-moment series and cutoff scan were computed with Quantum ESPRESSO 7.5 (GBRV ultrasoft pseudopotentials, 40/480 Ry, 4×4×1 k-mesh). GPAW was used for the surface-vacancy and hydrogen-pair structures. The two codes agree within 0.04 eV for the two unstrained adsorption energies. This supports those particular comparisons; other configurations and barriers require their own checks. Independent scripts recompute energy differences from saved outputs to verify the arithmetic.
Migration paths were sampled with the nudged-elastic-band (NEB) method: intermediate structures ("images") between relaxed endpoints are connected and relaxed to approximate a path. A climbing image locates a saddle candidate; the forward barrier is its energy above the starting state. The octa saddle received an additional 4×4×1 single-point evaluation; the tetra saddle did not, and its last recorded force remained 0.117 eV/Å.
Surface coverage and bulk vacancies (campaign 3). Surface energies use GPAW at 4×4×1 with 6×6×1 sensitivity checks. The bulk-vacancy series uses spin-polarized Quantum ESPRESSO with GBRV pseudopotentials and 40/480 Ry cutoffs. A 7.048 Å cubic cell repeats in all three directions and contains 31 Ni atoms plus 1–6 H. Only H positions were relaxed, at 2×2×2; final energy evaluations use 3×3×3. All Ni positions and the cell dimensions were fixed.
Equilibrium occupancy model. The vacancy energies are combined with an ideal-gas H₂ chemical potential, which describes the free-energy cost of supplying H at a given temperature and pressure. Gas translation, rotation, vibration and zero-point energy—the vibrational energy present even at zero temperature—are included. Solid-state vibrational free energies and alternative arrangements at each occupancy are omitted.
Bulk escape path. The GPAW calculation uses a 500 eV cutoff, fixed Ni positions, four intermediate NEB structures, a 3×3×1 path mesh and a 4×4×1 saddle energy evaluation. Its final residual force is 0.218 eV/Å, above the 0.12 eV/Å target, so the path is incompletely converged. The destination is a bulk octahedral site; some archived filenames label it tetrahedral.
Adsorption energies are in eV relative to ½H₂ gas; reaction energies and entry barriers are relative to the fcc surface state. Different coverage, functionals and zero-point treatments limit numerical comparison.
Scroll the table sideways to see all site energies and barriers →
| Study | fcc | bridge | top | octa | ΔE (octa − fcc) | fcc → octa barrier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bhatia and Sholl 2005 [1] 0.25 ML, ZPE corrected | −0.486 | −0.373 | −0.126 | +0.113 | +0.599 | 0.837 (19.3 kcal/mol) |
| Ledentu et al. 2000 [2] 1/3 ML, no ZPE | −0.66 | — | — | +0.05 | +0.71 | — |
| Shirazi et al. 2017 [3] 0.25 ML | — | — | — | — | +0.32 | 0.47 |
| This work 0.25 ML, no ZPE | −0.519 | −0.377 | +0.037 | +0.178 | +0.697 | 0.846 |
Bhatia and Sholl [1] report the same surface-over-subsurface ordering and a 0.837 eV fcc-to-octa barrier, close to our 0.846 eV result but with zero-point corrections not applied here. Shirazi [3] reports a 0.32 eV reaction energy at 0.25 ML, not an octa adsorption energy relative to gas. Henkelman and Arnaldsson [4] find the subsurface site about 0.6 eV above fcc; their 0.82 eV recombination barrier is a different process. Absolute site energies and barriers should not be treated as a 20 meV cross-study validation. The repository audits re-derive the quoted internal arithmetic; they do not test these literature comparisons.
3The structure: slab, sites, and routes
Surface hollows lie between three top-layer Ni atoms; fcc and hcp identify the stacking of the layers below them. Beneath the surface, an octahedral interstitial has six neighboring Ni atoms and a tetrahedral interstitial has four. The figures abbreviate these sites as octa and tetra.
4Adsorption energies at six sites
The sites below are possible resting positions for H on or beneath Ni(111). The adsorption energy Eads compares the structure with H to the clean slab plus half an H₂ molecule, the electronic gas reference for one H atom. Negative values indicate energy release; positive values indicate an energy cost. Occupancy at finite temperature and pressure additionally depends on free energies and competition between sites.
| Site | Geometry | Eads (k₄₄₁) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| fcc | Threefold surface hollow, no atom directly beneath (ABC stacking) | −0.519 eV | Global minimum. Anchors: −0.486 eV (Bhatia & Sholl 2005 [1], ZPE-corrected), −0.66 eV (Ledentu 2000 [2], no ZPE) |
| hcp | Threefold hollow above a second-layer atom | −0.503 eV | 16 meV above fcc |
| bridge | Twofold bridge | −0.377 eV | Metastable. Anchor: −0.373 eV (Bhatia & Sholl 2005 [1]) — 4 meV from ours |
| top | On top of one atom | +0.037 eV | Unfavorable relative to fcc; Bhatia and Sholl [1] report −0.126 eV with zero-point corrections |
| octa | Subsurface octahedral interstice (6 Ni neighbours), directly below the fcc hollow | +0.178 eV | The subsurface loading target, endothermic at zero strain (section 5) |
| tetra | Subsurface tetrahedral interstice (4 Ni neighbours), laterally displaced 1.44 Å (section 6) | +0.511 eV | Strongly endothermic, displaced exit geometry |
A 17.6 meV change in the fcc adsorption energy between 4×4×1 and 6×6×1 meshes measures one numerical sensitivity; it does not bound all site energies. Zero-point and vibrational free-energy corrections have not been applied. The comparison with [1] is consequently about the ordering, not a common absolute-energy precision.
The fcc surface site lies 0.697 eV below subsurface octa in the unstrained 0.25 ML model. Strong H binding at the surface therefore does not imply a large population of interior H structures. For the stated lattice objective, surface adsorption and hydrogen organized within nickel are distinct material properties; this site comparison establishes that distinction under the sampled conditions.
The six-coordinate octahedral site lies 0.333 eV below the four-coordinate tetrahedral site, although both are above the sampled fcc surface site. For a vacancy-centered H arrangement, the shape and openness of the surrounding Ni cage therefore matter to its energy, while coordination number alone is insufficient because site geometry changes at the same time. This is a local structural criterion, not a universal rule for defects.
5Strain and site energies
At the three sampled lattice constants, octahedral adsorption changes from +0.169 eV at −2% to +0.178 eV at zero and −0.030 eV at +2%. The corresponding fcc values are −0.581, −0.519 and −0.693 eV. The surface–octa energy gap narrows from 0.750 to 0.697 to 0.663 eV; the gas-reference crossing at +2% does not reverse the site preference. Tensile loading, alloy composition and magnetic transitions could change lattice dimensions, but these calculations do not establish that any particular alloy or Curie transition produces the imposed strain.
At +2% strain, octahedral adsorption moves just below the gas reference, but fcc remains 0.663 eV lower; across the sampled endpoints the fcc–octa gap narrows by only 0.087 eV. Thus imposed strain alone does not make the clean subsurface site the preferred H location, limiting its value as a stand-alone route to the interior arrangement. Strain response of defect-bound H is unknown.
The magnetic state (campaign 2)
Campaign 2 constrained the slab's total magnetic moment and recomputed the fcc and octa energies (section 9.2). Their gap changes across the imposed series, while the clean reference is unequally constrained at high moment and the low-moment electronic states are uncharacterized. The data show sensitivity to the imposed electronic state; they do not assign a direct magnetic contribution to uptake or represent the finite-temperature Curie transition.
At +2% strain, the octahedral site's −0.030 eV adsorption energy is favorable relative to ½H₂, yet its energy remains 0.663 eV above fcc. The gas reference asks whether adding H is energetically favorable; the site gap asks whether H prefers the surface or subsurface. For an interior population, both site competition and access kinetics matter; this calculation addresses neither finite-pressure loading nor defect trapping.
6Migration barriers
fcc to octa
Forward barrier 0.846 eV, reverse 0.149 eV (4×4×1 single points). Bhatia and Sholl [1] report 0.837 eV for fcc→octa with zero-point corrections; Shirazi et al. [3] report 0.47 eV at 0.25 ML with different computational choices. The present model predicts a high clean-surface entry barrier and a low reverse barrier; neither was recalculated under strain.
fcc to tetra
Forward barrier ≈ 1.07 eV, reverse 0.034 eV at the 3×3×1 mesh. The tetra well is higher in energy than octa, and its interstice lies 1.44 Å laterally displaced from the fcc hollow (the octa site is in-column). A straight-line initial band drove H into the close-packed Ni layer and produced an unphysical +10 eV wall; the revised path descends in-column before crossing the open interlayer gap into the displaced cage (pink dashed route in the 3D view). The 34 meV exit barrier implies rapid thermal escape at the plotted temperatures under the same illustrative attempt frequency; the tetra saddle was not separately refined at 4×4×1.
The calculated fcc-to-octa path has a 0.846 eV entry barrier and a 0.149 eV return barrier, so H is much more readily returned along this route than retained below the terrace. A viable interior-H lattice must be judged by both capture and retention, rather than favorable endpoint binding alone; this single clean-surface path does not represent every loading protocol.
7Escape times and their assumptions
Residence time is the average time an H atom stays before escaping. In a simple thermally activated model, τ = ν⁻¹exp(E/kBT), where E is the escape barrier and ν is an attempt frequency. We use ν = 10¹³ s⁻¹ as an illustration. The calculated 0.149 eV clean-surface return barrier gives about 32 ps at 300 K. This estimate applies to that site and path.
The sampled fixed-Ni route out of the six-H vacancy state rises by 2.414 eV. This is a larger kinetic obstacle than clean-surface return, but the path is incomplete and is not established as the easiest exit. Its design meaning is a distinction between favorable binding and a route-dependent kinetic barrier; it cannot assign a material retention time.
The clean subsurface site returns to the surface in about 32 ps at 300 K under the assumed attempt frequency. That is an internal migration time, not a gas-desorption time. Likewise, the vacancy path leads to a bulk interstitial. The relevant design property is persistence of a particular interior H arrangement, which is distinct from the duration of total hydrogen storage.
8Site and saddle energies
At +2% strain the octa minimum moves below the gas reference, but the fcc minimum remains lower by 0.663 eV. The plotted saddles and reverse barriers were calculated at zero strain. No barrier change or bulk loading under strain follows from this diagram.
At zero strain, perfect-lattice octahedral and tetrahedral sites are uphill by +0.178 and +0.511 eV relative to ½H₂, while all six additions in the separate vacancy calculation are favorable at that electronic reference. This makes defect-centered H a stronger candidate for the intended interior structure than regular interstitial H in these models; it does not determine solubility at all pressures or behavior of every defect.
9Magnetism, a surface vacancy and hydrogen pairs
The fixed-moment, surface-vacancy and two-H results distinguish changes in the local environment from a simple increase in H inventory. Quantum ESPRESSO provides the unstrained reference comparison and the constrained-moment series; GPAW provides the vacancy and pair structures. Their design meaning is specific to the configurations and constraints below.
9.1 Cross-check with a second code
The two codes use different treatments of core electrons and basis conventions. Agreement for these two configurations supports the numerical stability of these energies, but it does not validate the strain slope, migration barriers or higher-coverage behavior. The campaign plan specified ±0.05 eV for the cross-code comparison; the audit script enforces a looser 0.20 eV check.
GPAW and Quantum ESPRESSO agree within 0.04 eV for the unstrained fcc and octahedral adsorption energies. This supports the clean-terrace surface preference as a numerical baseline for the design argument, while saying nothing about DFT accuracy or validating strain, barriers, vacancy binding, or loaded structures. Its value is confidence in the specific reference comparison, not a general error bar.
9.2 Site energies at fixed magnetic moment
Across the constrained points, octa adsorption spans 0.861 eV and fcc adsorption spans 0.161 eV, including the reference-affected 10 μB point. The octa-minus-fcc gap falls from 1.355 to 0.639 eV. This is a correlation within imposed, zero-temperature electronic states, not a Curie-temperature response. The low-moment output needed to characterize the electronic branches was overwritten; the clean reference is constrained differently from the H-loaded slabs at high moment. The size and sign of any direct magnetic contribution to subsurface occupation remain unresolved.
Across the sampled fixed-moment electronic states, octahedral H remains less favorable than fcc, despite a large change in their energy gap. In this calculation, altering total moment alone does not reverse the clean-surface preference, so magnetism is not established as a switch for interior loading; it remains a possible host-response variable in vacancy-bound structures. Electronic branches and references are incompletely characterized.
9.3 A vacancy in the surface, and hydrogen pairs
Surface vacancy. H placed below a missing top-layer Ni atom relaxed to the rim of the opening. In the separate bulk-vacancy model, H remains at neighboring interior sites through six sampled additions (section 10.2). Defect location therefore matters in these models. The surface model's 0.602 eV surface–subsurface difference is not a controlled trap depth: its two structures froze 7 and 4 Ni atoms. The clean comparison used different settings, and the separately labeled bare-vacancy structure removed a bottom-layer atom. These mismatches prevent a quantitative vacancy-effect estimate.
In the sampled slab, H placed below a missing top-layer Ni atom relaxes to the vacancy rim. An opening connected directly to the surface therefore does not create the buried H environment sought for a local H/Ni mode in this geometry; defect depth and openness matter to lattice design. The energy comparison uses unmatched frozen-Ni frames and cannot quantify a trap depth.
Hydrogen pairs. The sampled subsurface pair has an H–H spacing of 2.49 Å and an interaction energy of 0.00–0.02 eV. A mixed surface/subsurface pair at 3.05 Å has an interaction energy of about +0.06 eV. Positive values indicate an energy cost, so the sampled configurations provide no evidence of pair attraction. Two subsurface inputs are the same periodic arrangement; their 0.02 eV difference indicates numerical sensitivity. The vacancy shell's favorable binding can therefore be interpreted as stabilization by the defect and shared Ni environment, without attributing it to dilute H–H attraction. These pair results do not determine interactions or collective motion at higher occupancy.
The surface vacancy relaxes H to its rim, whereas a separate bulk-vacancy model stabilizes H in six neighboring interstitial positions. The contrast identifies buried free volume as the geometry associated with the sampled multi-H state and distinguishes it from surface adsorption; defect location therefore matters to the intended local structure. The two models differ, so this is not a universal rule for vacancies.
9.4 Cutoff test
The fcc adsorption energy changes by 18 meV over the 30–50 Ry scan, and by about 0.1 meV between 40 and 50 Ry. This is a sensitivity check for the executed GBRV ultrasoft protocol: the charge-density cutoff is twelve times the wavefunction cutoff. The originally planned PSL PAW settings differ from those used, as documented in the archive. This check supports the chosen basis for this fcc energy; it is not an error bound for other sites or barriers.
At the sampled separations, pair interaction energies are near zero or slightly repulsive, while the bulk vacancy still accommodates several H in a defined geometry. This points to the Ni vacancy's available positions, rather than direct H–H attraction at dilute separation, as the source of local organization in the candidate structure. The pair results do not cover loaded surfaces or the vacancy shell.
The saved structures, outputs and arithmetic checks are documented in campaign-2 RESULT.md. Section 10 gives the separate bulk-vacancy results; section 11 relates them to the stated lattice objective.
10Surface coverage and hydrogen at a bulk vacancy
Campaign 3 asks whether adding more H to the surface changes subsurface preference, and whether a vacancy inside the metal binds several H atoms. Saved final structures and energies provide the binding sequence. A separate equilibrium model estimates filling at different gas conditions; magnetic moments and forces show how filling changes the fixed Ni host.
10.1 Selected surface arrangements and subsurface uptake
Successive surface additions have energies of −0.506, −0.610, −0.201 and −0.674 eV relative to half-H₂. The irregular sequence reflects changes in the selected surface arrangements as well as coverage. Adding one subsurface H costs +0.685, +0.635 and +0.599 eV at 0.25, 0.5 and 0.75 ML: an 86 meV reduction, with insertion still unfavorable in each case. The saturated surface plus an additional subsurface H is outside the sampled set.
At 0.5 and 0.75 ML, the total energies of the surface-plus-subsurface cells are negative relative to gas, but conditional insertion of the additional subsurface H is still positive. Total cell stability and the preference for the next H answer different questions.
For the selected surface states, adding one subsurface H remains uphill from 0.25 to 0.75 ML, although the cost falls by 86 meV across the series. Coverage and arrangement change together, so higher coverage is a possible supply-side influence but not a demonstrated route to the interior H state. This distinction keeps surface storage separate from vacancy-bound occupancy.
10.2 H binding at six sites around a bulk vacancy
Total binding is −0.349, −0.684, −0.972, −1.262, −1.543 and −1.824 eV for n = 1…6. The incremental binding energies below identify the cost of each occupancy change. Subtracting the bulk-H reference from gas requires the independently computed +0.14725 eV/H solution offset.
| n | Total binding vs bulk H (eV) | nth-H binding vs bulk H (eV) | nth-H addition vs ½H₂ (eV) | Final minimum H–H (Å) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | -0.349 | -0.349 | -0.202 | single H |
| 2 | -0.684 | -0.335 | -0.188 | 2.865 |
| 3 | -0.971 | -0.288 | -0.140 | 2.347 |
| 4 | -1.261 | -0.290 | -0.143 | 2.377 |
| 5 | -1.543 | -0.282 | -0.135 | 2.400 |
| 6 | -1.824 | -0.281 | -0.133 | 2.443 |
Relative to the electronic gas reference, the first H addition releases about 0.202 eV and the sixth about 0.133 eV. Binding weakens as the shell fills but remains favorable through all six sampled additions. This gives a vacancy-supported six-site arrangement without establishing a maximum capacity or a kinetic filling rate.
With H positions relaxed but Ni fixed, each of six sampled vacancy-adjacent sites binds H relative to bulk-dissolved hydrogen; the sixth still gains 0.281 eV. This defines a concrete local multi-H geometry that could supply the structural basis for coupled H/Ni motion, rather than evidence that six is a universal capacity. Neither host relaxation nor a seventh H was included.
10.3 Estimated filling at different temperatures and pressures
The question here is how many H atoms an existing vacancy would hold at equilibrium with H₂ gas. The binding energies in section 10.2 compare vacancy-bound H with H dissolved in bulk nickel. To compare with gas supply, we add the bulk-H solution energy, +0.14725 eV per H relative to half an H₂ molecule. Temperature and pressure then enter through the gas chemical potential.
In equations, ΔEsol = E(bulk+H) − E(bulk) − ½E(H₂), and δμgas(T,p) = ½[μH₂(T,p) − E(H₂)]. For n H atoms, Ωn = Ebind(n) + nΔEsol − nδμgas. Ωn is the relative state energy after allowing exchange of H with the gas. The probability P(n) is proportional to exp[−Ωn/(kBT)] and normalized over n = 0…6. This approximation uses one sampled structure at each occupancy. P₆ means the probability of six H at an existing vacancy, not the fraction of Ni sites that contain such a vacancy.
| T (K) | p (bar) | Most likely n | P₆ | Mean H per vacancy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 300 | 1 | 6 | 0.98700 | 5.987 |
| 300 | 100 | 6 | 0.99870 | 5.999 |
| 400 | 1 | 6 | 0.71502 | 5.619 |
| 400 | 100 | 6 | 0.97076 | 5.970 |
| 500 | 1 | 2 | 0.02730 | 2.334 |
| 500 | 100 | 6 | 0.79551 | 5.748 |
| 600 | 1 | 0 | 0.00003 | 0.530 |
| 600 | 100 | 6 | 0.30375 | 4.435 |
Within this model, six-H shells dominate at 300 K for the two sampled pressures. At 500 K and 1 bar, P₆ falls to about 0.027, but the vacancy is not generally empty: its mean occupancy is 2.33 H. At 100 bar, the mean is 5.75 H and P₆ is about 0.796. Thus partial and full shells are distinct modeled material states, with different local symmetry and magnetic environments. The omitted solid free energies and alternative arrangements limit the precision of their predicted populations.
Sensitivity of the occupancy interpretation. At 500 K/1 bar, a hypothetical solid free-energy change of −0.05 eV per H raises P₆ to about 0.414; +0.05 eV lowers it to about 0.00014. Assigning the idealized number of arrangements g(n)=C(6,n)—the number of ways to occupy n of six equivalent sites—gives P₆ ≈ 0.00225 at the baseline energies. These are sensitivity scenarios, not calculated corrections. They show that a favorable binding sequence alone does not fix the full-shell fraction.
Conditional on an existing vacancy, the model gives mean occupancy of 2.33 H at 500 K and 1 bar versus 5.75 H at 100 bar, changing the balance between partial and nearly complete filling. Occupancy is therefore a potential control on the symmetry and local magnetic or mechanical state of the H arrangement relevant to coherence-domain hypotheses. Solid vibrations and alternative arrangements could shift these predictions.
10.4 One calculated escape path through the fixed host
The destination is +0.331 eV above the starting state at the 3×3×1 mesh, whereas the sampled path rises about 2.410 eV. At its highest-energy structure, the migrating H comes within about 1.246 Å of two Ni atoms, compared with roughly 1.76 Å at the destination. Most of the barrier therefore reflects passage through a tight region of the fixed host, rather than the loss of vacancy binding alone.
The path has four intermediate structures and a final residual force of 0.218 eV/Å. Small late-step energy drift describes optimizer behavior, not a bound on the barrier error. Ni atoms were fixed, and the bulk k-point meshes sampled the three axes unequally. The 2.414 eV value characterizes this incomplete path; it does not establish the lowest physical exit barrier or the lifetime of vacancy-bound H.
10.5 Vacancy formation and hydrogen binding are separate
A filled vacancy can bind H favorably while still costing energy to create. We estimate the formation energy of an empty vacancy by comparing its cell with the corresponding number of atoms in perfect nickel: Ef(V) = E(V) − (31/32)E(Ni₃₂). Adding n H atoms from the electronic gas reference gives Ef(VHn;½H₂) = Ef(V) + Ebind(n) + nΔEsol. The table describes these fixed-host electronic energies.
| State | Electronic formation energy vs Ni + H₂ (eV) |
|---|---|
| VH0 | 1.614 |
| VH1 | 1.412 |
| VH2 | 1.224 |
| VH3 | 1.084 |
| VH4 | 0.941 |
| VH5 | 0.807 |
| VH6 | 0.673 |
H binding reduces the calculated vacancy formation energy from 1.614 to 0.673 eV for six H, while leaving it positive at the electronic Ni/H₂ reference. At finite temperature and pressure, gas chemical potential, solid free energies and entropy also contribute. Favorable filling and plentiful vacancies are therefore separate properties. The fixed-host electronic estimates describe hydrogen stabilization of the modeled defect, not an experimental vacancy concentration.
Hydrogen lowers the calculated vacancy-formation energy from 1.614 to 0.673 eV for the six-H state but leaves it positive at the electronic gas reference. Thus local occupancy and the number of available H-bearing regions are separate material variables: a strongly occupied vacancy population cannot be inferred from binding energy alone. The calculation fixes Ni and omits defect entropy, so it does not establish real vacancy abundance.
10.6 Surface arrangement matters as well as mean coverage
We compare each sampled surface structure with mixtures of structures at neighboring H counts. At zero temperature, the lowest-energy combinations use the zero-, two- and four-H structures. This set is the lower convex envelope, or convex hull, of the calculated energies. The one-H state is about 52 meV above the zero/two-H mixture; the three-H state is about 236 meV above the two/four-H mixture. The corresponding electronic chemical-potential transitions are about −0.558 and −0.437 eV per H relative to half-H₂.
The result suggests that average coverage may hide distinct local arrangements. To assess entry below the surface, compare H insertion and migration on those arrangements, including boundaries between differently covered regions.
These energetic preferences apply to the selected structures at zero temperature. Alternative arrangements, boundaries between surface regions and entropy can change them; the result is not a complete surface phase diagram.
The same ordering appears at the denser 6×6×1 mesh. At equal total H count, the selected subsurface-containing cells are 1.295, 0.836 and 1.272 eV above their all-surface counterparts for two, three and four H. In these configurations, concentrating H on the surface remains energetically preferable to placing one atom below it.
Among the calculated zero- to four-H surface states, the 0-, 2- and 4-H arrangements are lower in energy; the 1- and 3-H states lie above mixtures of neighboring arrangements. The same average coverage can therefore conceal different local order, which may alter competition between surface H and interior sites. This finite-cell, zero-temperature ordering does not establish a measured phase sequence.
10.7 Calculated local Ni moments decrease as H is added
| n | QE net moment (μB) | QE absolute moment (μB) | Projected atomic sum (μB) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 22.38 | 25.67 | 23.782 |
| 1 | 21.85 | 24.96 | 22.462 |
| 2 | 21.36 | 24.40 | 21.973 |
| 3 | 20.66 | 23.58 | 21.037 |
| 4 | 20.21 | 23.09 | 20.661 |
| 5 | 19.61 | 22.31 | 19.970 |
| 6 | 19.12 | 21.71 | 19.448 |
The cell magnetic moment decreases as the vacancy fills. To locate this change, we also examine spin density integrated over spheres around individual atoms. These local moments describe the calculated distribution of magnetism; they depend on the projection used and are distinct from the total cell moment.
The nearest 12 Ni fall from a mean 0.7895 to 0.5316 μB per sphere between empty and six-H states, a 32.7% reduction; farther Ni fall from 0.7531 to 0.6905 μB, about 8.3%. Partial shells give unequal nearest-Ni moments, while the full shell restores equivalent moments among those atoms. H sphere moments are small and oppositely signed (about −0.0083 μB per H at n=6). Filling changes the magnetic environment most strongly close to the vacancy, even with the Ni positions held fixed.
The sphere-projected mean moment on the twelve nearest Ni atoms falls by 32.7% between empty and six-H vacancy states, a stronger change than on more distant Ni. H occupancy therefore changes the local magnetic environment that could participate in host-mediated interactions or damping in a coherence-domain picture. The projection is a calculated local descriptor, not a validated experimental readout of occupancy.
10.8 H filling changes forces on the fixed Ni atoms
The mean radial force on Ni nearest an empty vacancy points inward at −0.1785 eV/Å. It changes sign between two and three H and reaches +0.4260 eV/Å outward at six H. Because Ni atoms were held fixed, these residual forces indicate a tendency to move; the calculation does not give the resulting displacement or strain.
The occupancy-dependent forces connect H filling to the surrounding metal's tendency to deform. For a proposed collective response involving H and Ni motion, the host is therefore an occupancy-dependent part of the local structure. Residual forces do not specify the relaxed displacement, vibration frequencies or coupling between separate vacancies.
The mean radial force on Ni nearest the vacancy changes from inward to outward between two and three H. Occupancy therefore changes the tendency for local host deformation as well as hydrogen inventory. For a proposed collective response involving H and Ni, this makes the host state part of the material description; the constrained forces do not specify actual displacement or coupled motion.
11What the vacancy results imply for the LENR lattice objective
The stated objective is a nickel lattice with hydrogen-containing structures that could participate in coherence domains associated with low-energy nuclear reaction (LENR) activity. A vacancy is a missing Ni atom; the occupancy n is the number of H atoms in the six interstitial positions adjacent to it. The calculations give this objective a concrete local structural motif, an occupancy landscape, and evidence that the Ni host responds as the motif fills. They define candidate features of a material; they do not show that coherence or an LENR response has been achieved.
11.1 A vacancy organizes six H sites in a shared Ni environment
After H relaxation, the six positions form an approximately octahedral shell around the missing Ni atom. Each H has five nearby Ni neighbours, while H–H edge separations are close to the spacing between ordinary bulk octahedral sites and far greater than the compact H₂ bond. The result is a distributed, lattice-organized ensemble rather than a molecular H₂ unit. The shared vacancy geometry brings six H atoms into a defined symmetry-related arrangement.
All six additions bind favorably relative to bulk-dissolved H in the sampled fixed-host calculation. The binding gained per addition decreases from 0.349 eV for the first H to 0.281 eV for the sixth. The dilute pair interactions sampled at 2.49 and 3.05 Å are near zero to weakly repulsive. Thus favorable multi-H binding is established within the vacancy environment, while direct H–H attraction is not established by the pair results. The design significance is several H atoms sharing an altered Ni environment; the calculations do not isolate every contribution to their binding. Ni positions were fixed, and occupancies above six were not sampled.
11.2 Occupancy changes the structure that the lattice presents
The full shell is the high-symmetry limit. Partial shells have fewer H atoms and break that symmetry in occupancy-dependent ways; they are distinct local structures, not simply a lower average hydrogen concentration. This matters to the stated objective because a lattice intended to support a particular collective response must be described by the occupied structure, not only by its total H/Ni ratio.
The reservoir model assigns high full-shell probability at 300 K: P6 ≈ 0.987 at 1 bar and 0.999 at 100 bar. At 500 K it gives 0.027 at 1 bar and 0.796 at 100 bar. Within this model, temperature and hydrogen pressure can select markedly different occupancy distributions for vacancies that already exist. These are conditional probabilities from one sampled arrangement per occupancy, with solid vibrational free energies and alternative-configuration multiplicities omitted; they describe a thermodynamic trend, not a measured isotherm.
The calculated Ni response also depends on occupancy. From an empty to a six-H vacancy, the mean sphere-projected moment on the nearest twelve Ni decreases by 32.7%, compared with 8.3% on the other Ni atoms. The mean radial force on the nearest Ni changes from inward to outward between n = 2 and 3. Because the Ni atoms were fixed, these forces are residual forces rather than a relaxed strain. Together, the moment and force trends show that the H shell changes the local electronic and mechanical environment of its host. In this material concept, nickel is part of the candidate ensemble, not a passive container.
11.3 Defect abundance, occupancy, and host response set different parts of the design
The occupancy calculation is conditional on a vacancy being present. The bare vacancy has positive formation energy in the fixed-host model, and hydrogen lowers that energy without making formation favorable at the electronic gas reference, even for VH₆. A high probability of filling an existing vacancy therefore does not imply a high concentration of filled vacancies. The number of candidate local structures and the hydrogen population within each structure are separate material variables.
The bulk calculation repeats one vacancy every 7.048 Å, or one vacancy per 32 parent Ni sites. At full occupancy this cell has H/Ni = 6/31 ≈ 0.194; it represents a specified periodic concentration rather than a general dilute limit. If fv is the fraction of parent Ni sites that are vacancies and ⟨n⟩ the conditional mean occupancy, the vacancy-bound contribution to H/Ni is ⟨n⟩fv/(1−fv). For cubic lattice parameter a, the estimated density of full shells is 4fvP6/a3, assuming independent vacancies and four parent Ni atoms per conventional cell. These relations estimate the vacancy-bound contribution to inventory under the stated assumptions; they do not specify interactions or correlated behavior between shells.
Illustrative vacancy-bound hydrogen concentration
K bar
Population accounting for independent existing vacancies, using the section 10.3 reservoir model. The mean spacing is inferred from vacancy density; it is not a calculated interaction distance or a coherence-domain size.
For the stated lattice objective, vacancy fraction sets how many local H arrangements are available, occupancy sets their internal structure, and the host response changes with filling. A dense population supplies more copies of the candidate local H arrangement. Density alone says nothing about whether their motions or electronic responses are coupled; neither proximity nor total H inventory establishes a coherence domain.
11.4 Relation to the coherence-domain hypothesis
Here, coherence means a reproducible phase relationship between motions or fields at different locations that persists over space and time. A vacancy-bound shell is a candidate local structure; it is not itself a coherence domain. Bressani, Del Giudice and Preparata [7] proposed coherent coupling through the quantized electromagnetic field, and Preparata [5] develops the broader framework. In that context, the present results identify a specific lattice environment whose occupancy changes its local electronic and mechanical descriptors. They do not calculate the phase relationships, spatial extent, or lifetime required to identify coherent behavior, and no LENR response is measured here.
The material-design meaning is specific: the vacancy supports several H atoms in a defined local arrangement, the reservoir model allows different filling states, and filling changes the surrounding nickel. These are structural and electronic properties relevant to a mechanism in which the host mediates collective behavior. Extended vibrational correlations would describe coupled motion; the cited electromagnetic-coherence proposal additionally concerns coupling and phase relationships between matter and fields. Neither response is determined by the present static calculations. Prior Ni-vacancy studies [8–10] provide the established defect-binding context.
12What these results mean for the LENR lattice objective
The calculations constrain what a candidate lattice must contain and distinguish several functions that can otherwise be conflated. The table summarizes the material-design meaning supported by the present results.
| Design dimension | Result in this study | Meaning for the stated objective | What the result establishes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Local structure | Six H occupy symmetry-related interstitial positions around one missing Ni, with 2.443 Å shell edges; the H–H distances are much larger than a compact H₂ molecule. | The candidate local unit is organized by a shared vacancy environment, not by H–H molecular pairing or a flat terrace alone. | A relaxed-H, fixed-Ni geometry and favorable binding through the six sampled positions; not a dynamic mode. |
| Hydrogen inventory and symmetry | All six additions bind relative to bulk H; calculated P6 changes strongly with temperature and pressure. Partial occupancy changes the shell symmetry. | Different modeled filling states present different local structures. Total H/Ni alone does not identify vacancy occupancy, because H can also occupy surfaces, ordinary interstitials and other defects. | A conditional reservoir-model distribution with missing solid free energies and configuration multiplicities. |
| Number of local units | Vacancy formation remains energetically costly even for VH₆; the simulated crystal contains one vacancy per 32 parent Ni sites. | Vacancy abundance is separate from the ability to fill a vacancy. Hydrogen capacity per defect cannot be equated with the density of candidate structures. | A fixed-host formation-energy estimate and one periodic concentration. |
| Participation of the Ni host | Nearest-Ni projected moments decrease by 32.7% across shell filling; the mean radial force changes sign between n = 2 and 3. | The local electronic and mechanical environment varies with occupancy, so the host is part of the material unit relevant to the objective. | Calculated local moments and residual forces with Ni fixed, not a measured magnetic, elastic, or collective response. |
| Organization beyond one vacancy | The calculations describe a periodic single-vacancy cell and local shell properties; they do not report phase correlations between separate shells. | A material-scale coherence domain would require more than many occupied defects: the local structures would have to participate in correlated behavior across space and time. | A distinction implied by the coherence-domain hypothesis, not a property established by these calculations. |
| Hydrogen supply and retention | Clean-surface fcc H is 0.697 eV below subsurface octa H; +2% strain narrows the gap to 0.663 eV. One fixed-host vacancy escape corridor has a 2.414 eV barrier. | Surface loading, vacancy occupancy, and retention are separate aspects of the material. The calculations identify strong surface preference and a potentially restrictive sampled escape path, but do not quantify vacancy loading or lifetime. | Site energies and one path-specific barrier; not a bulk transport rate or a physical retention time. |
The supported design concept is a nickel host containing buried vacancies, with hydrogen distributed in occupancy-dependent shells and a local host response tied to filling. The calculated geometry and binding make these shells plausible local components of the proposed LENR lattice. Their material-scale abundance, interaction and coherent response are separate properties; an LENR benefit does not follow from the binding result alone.
13Hydrogen supply, capture, and retention
The clean Ni(111) results explain why surface H inventory and vacancy occupancy are different material properties. The fcc surface site is 0.697 eV below subsurface octa, and entry has a 0.846 eV barrier while return has a 0.149 eV barrier. An illustrative attempt frequency of 1013 s−1 gives about 0.06 entry events per second per occupied starting site and a subsurface residence of about 32 ps at 300 K. Assuming equal site degeneracy and neglecting vibrational free-energy differences, the Boltzmann subsurface/surface population ratio is about 2 × 10−12. These path and site estimates express strong surface preference; they do not describe capture by an interior vacancy.
Imposed +2% strain makes subsurface octahedral adsorption slightly exothermic relative to H₂ gas, but fcc surface adsorption remains 0.663 eV lower. In the selected loaded-surface arrangements, adding a subsurface H still costs 0.599–0.685 eV. Thus, neither the sampled strain nor surface coverage overturns the calculated surface preference. For a lattice intended to contain vacancy-bound hydrogen, the internal defect trap—not the clean terrace—is the calculated source of favorable hydrogen storage.
The sampled vacancy escape corridor rises by 2.414 eV but was calculated with the Ni host fixed, four interior images, and a residual saddle force of 0.218 eV/Å. It identifies a high-energy route in that model, not the lowest escape route or a quantitative lifetime. The result is consistent with loading and retention being distinct: occupancy thermodynamics describe how favorable the filled shell is under a reservoir, while a path barrier describes only one possible kinetic route out. Neither quantity establishes a collective response.
13aDesign constraints distilled from the present calculations
Three conditions are distinct in the evidence: a material must contain vacancies, those vacancies must be occupied, and any coherence-domain interpretation requires correlated response across multiple local structures. The positive vacancy formation energy separates the first condition from the second; the occupancy model addresses the second only conditionally; the calculations do not address the third.
The resulting concept is a population of buried vacancies containing defined H arrangements, with filling and the local Ni environment changing together. The central design variables are the number of these arrangements, their occupancy and symmetry, and their relationship through the host. The calculations describe the local structure and state changes; they do not establish a coherent response or LENR activity.
References
The original comparison papers are deposited under literature/ in the repository. Additional theory and vacancy references below are linked to the primary publications. The table in section 2 separates adsorption energies relative to gas from fcc-to-octa reaction energies and barriers.
- B. Bhatia and D. S. Sholl, "Chemisorption and diffusion of hydrogen on surface and subsurface sites of flat and stepped nickel surfaces", J. Chem. Phys. 122, 204707 (2005). doi:10.1063/1.1902943 — Ni(111) adsorption energies at 0.25 ML, zero-point corrected: fcc = hcp −11.2 kcal/mol (−0.486 eV), bridge −8.6, top −2.9, octa +2.6 kcal/mol (+0.113 eV). Table VI gives a fcc→octa activation energy of 19.3 kcal/mol (0.837 eV).
- V. Ledentu, W. Dong, and P. Sautet, "Heterogeneous catalysis through subsurface sites", J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122, 1796–1801 (2000). — fcc −0.66 eV at 1/3 ML without zero-point corrections; subsurface octahedral +0.05 eV; adsorption energies coverage-independent within 30 meV.
- M. Shirazi, A. Bogaerts, and E. C. Neyts, "A DFT study of H-dissolution into the bulk of a crystalline Ni(111) surface: a chemical identifier for the reaction kinetics", Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 19, 19150–19158 (2017). doi:10.1039/C7CP03662K — fcc→subsurface-octahedral barriers and reaction energies versus coverage: Ea 0.47 eV, ΔE +0.32 eV at 0.25 ML; exothermic only at ≥1 ML.
- G. Henkelman and A. Arnaldsson, "Theoretical calculations of CH4 and H2 associative desorption from Ni(111): Could subsurface hydrogen play an important role?", J. Chem. Phys. 124, 044706 (2006). — subsurface hydrogen's role in desorption; spin-polarized recombination barrier 0.82 eV.
- G. Preparata, QED Coherence in Matter, World Scientific, Singapore (1995). doi:10.1142/2738 — theoretical framework motivating the program's collective electromagnetic and matter-response questions.
- E. Storms, The Science of Low Energy Nuclear Reaction, World Scientific, Singapore (2007). — review volume collecting the experimental LENR record, including the loading-threshold observations discussed in section 11.
- T. Bressani, E. Del Giudice and G. Preparata, "First steps towards an understanding of ‘cold’ nuclear fusion", Il Nuovo Cimento A 101 (1989). doi:10.1007/BF02844877 — primary proposal connecting coherent quantized electromagnetic interactions, charged-particle interactions and energy transfer to metal electrons.
- H. Zheng, B. K. Rao, S. N. Khanna and P. Jena, "Electronic structure and binding energies of hydrogen-decorated vacancies in Ni", Physical Review B 55, 4174–4181 (1997). doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.55.4174 — precedent for multi-H Ni-vacancy binding and magnetic changes.
- D. Connétable et al., Ni vacancy–hydrogen DFT study (2014). doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2014.05.094 — vacancy segregation and multi-H cluster energetics.
- D. Tanguy et al., Ni vacancy–hydrogen cluster thermodynamics (2014). doi:10.1016/j.actamat.2014.06.021 — cluster stability versus hydrogen reservoir and temperature.
14Limitations
Configurations and free energies. The surface series samples selected arrangements in one 2×2 cell. Each vacancy occupancy up to six H is represented by one structure. The occupancy model includes gas vibration and zero-point energy, but omits solid vibrational free energies and the statistical weight of alternative H arrangements. Its temperature and pressure grid is illustrative.
Fixed host and concentration. H positions were relaxed while Ni and the cell dimensions were fixed. The periodic cell contains one vacancy per 32 parent sites (3.125%). Full Ni relaxation, lower vacancy concentrations, strain and alloying can change the geometry, energies and magnetic response.
Magnetic states. The constrained-moment surface series has unresolved electronic-state and reference issues. Vacancy sphere moments are local projections; they do not provide an experimental calibration of shell occupancy or an electronic damping rate.
Migration paths. The tetrahedral surface saddle lacks a 4×4×1 energy refinement. The bulk escape path has residual force 0.218 eV/Å, four intermediate structures, fixed Ni and unequal k-point sampling along the three bulk axes. Alternative exit paths were not calculated, so the vacancy barrier does not establish a material lifetime.
Research scope. This study identifies selected Ni–H structures and energy trends. Collective vibration spectra, coupling between vacancies, coherence lengths and times, and LENR outcomes require further calculations or measurements. The proposed connection between vacancy-bound H, coherence and LENR remains a hypothesis.
15Software and reproducibility
| Tool | Type | Role | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| GPAW 26.7 | Plane-wave DFT (PAW) | Campaign 1 site energies, strain points and barriers; campaign 2 surface-vacancy and pair frames; campaign 3 coverage, co-occupation and surface-NEB energies | Used at the documented settings; the published studies have different coverage and zero-point treatment |
| ASE 3.29 | Atomistics framework | Structure building, relaxations, climbing-image NEB, and the job drivers for both codes | In use, all three campaigns |
| Quantum ESPRESSO 7.5 with GBRV ultrasoft pseudopotentials | Independent plane-wave DFT | Campaign 2: cross-check of the fcc and octa site energies, the fixed-moment series, and the cutoff test (40/480 Ry, 4×4×1, 6 ranks). Campaign 3: the bulk-vacancy loading series and occupancy inputs (32-atom cell, 3×3×3 k-mesh) | In use. Agrees with GPAW within 0.04 eV on both sites |
| LAMMPS | Classical molecular dynamics | Long-time diffusion and many-hydrogen loading, once a Ni–H potential has been fitted to the DFT data of campaigns 1–3 | Installed. The potential fit is proposed, not started |
| SymPy / SciPy | Numeric checks | Independent numerical review of energy references, populations, final geometry, magnetic/force descriptors and published payloads | 109 numerical checks pass in the revised review; 72 source hashes match. Earlier campaigns retain their original arithmetic audits and mutation probes. |
16Glossary
- Adsorption / absorption
- H resting on the surface / dissolved inside the metal.
- Eads vs ½H₂
- Electronic energy change for adding one H atom, referenced to half an H₂ molecule. Negative releases energy; finite-temperature occupancy also depends on free energies, pressure and competing sites.
- eV, kBT
- Atomic energy unit. Thermal energy kBT ≈ 0.026 eV at 300 K and 0.060 eV at 700 K; a 0.85 eV barrier corresponds to ≈ 33 kBT at 300 K.
- fcc / hcp site
- The two threefold surface hollows of an fcc(111) surface (ABC versus ABA stacking above).
- octa / tetra site
- Subsurface interstitial cages with 6 / 4 Ni neighbours.
- Interstitial
- A small cavity between host atoms that a foreign atom can occupy.
- NEB, climbing image
- A method for refining a trial migration path between structures. The climbing image seeks the highest-energy saddle along that path. Other trial paths and convergence checks are needed to establish the lowest barrier.
- k-point mesh
- Numerical sampling of electronic states (3×3×1, 4×4×1); a denser mesh can expose sensitivity in an individual result. The 17.6 meV fcc difference between 4×4×1 and 6×6×1 is not a bound on other sites or barriers.
- Strain ε
- Relative stretch of the lattice constant. +2% means 2% longer.
- Magnetostriction, FM→PM
- A magnetic-state-dependent change in lattice dimensions; a ferromagnet loses long-range magnetic order above its Curie temperature. No lattice change through that transition was calculated here.
- Curie point TC
- Temperature where ferromagnetism vanishes (Ni: 627 K; alloys tune it down).
- Residence time τ
- Average time before thermal escape over a barrier: τ = ν⁻¹exp(E/kBT).
- Solubility / loading
- How much H the lattice holds at a given H₂ chemical potential; "loading" means driving it up.
- MLIP / EAM / ReaxFF
- Interaction models for classical MD; an MLIP is fitted to DFT data. The Ni–H fit is a proposed follow-up to campaign 2.
- Mutation audit
- Verification discipline: an independent script re-derives every quoted number from raw output, then a deliberate error is injected to confirm the script fails when it should. Campaign 1 passes 17 of 17 checks; each campaign-2 calculation has its own arithmetic check and deliberate-error probe.
- Cross-code check
- Computing selected configurations with two independent DFT implementations. Agreement for fcc and octa site energies tests those calculations under the stated settings; it does not validate other configurations or the underlying functional.
- Pseudopotential (PAW, ultrasoft)
- The treatment of the core electrons. GPAW uses the projector-augmented-wave method; the Quantum ESPRESSO runs used GBRV ultrasoft pseudopotentials. The two are built differently, which is what makes their agreement informative.
- Plane-wave cutoff (eV, Ry)
- The basis resolution: GPAW used 500 eV, Quantum ESPRESSO 40 Ry for wavefunctions and 480 Ry for charge density (1 Ry ≈ 13.6 eV). The section 9 scan probes the fcc site with GBRV ultrasoft pseudopotentials only.
- Fixed total moment, μB
- A calculation in which the net magnetic moment of the whole slab is held at a chosen value, measured in Bohr magnetons (each Ni atom carries about 0.6 μB in the ferromagnetic metal; the 16-atom slab about 12). Holding it below its natural value is a way to ask how the site energies depend on the magnetic state.
- Disordered local moments
- A possible model for the paramagnetic metal above TC, with local magnetic moments of varied orientation. Not computed here; a fixed-total-moment slab does not stand in for this finite-temperature state.
- Vacancy, Etrap
- A missing Ni atom. The trap binding energy is how much lower the energy is with H next to the vacancy than with H at the same kind of site far from it.
- Pair interaction Eint
- Energy difference between a two-H structure and matched separate-H references. Positive indicates an energetic penalty for the sampled pair; a value near zero indicates little net interaction at that geometry and numerical precision.
- Coverage (ML)
- Fraction of a full surface monolayer of hydrogen; 0.25 ML is one H per 2×2 cell. In campaign 3's co-occupation series one further H sits in the subsurface octa site beneath the loaded surface.
- Vacancy binding curve Ebind(n)
- Energy to move n H atoms from bulk solution sites into one vacancy. Negative values mean the H prefer the vacancy; campaign 3's curve is nearly linear to n = 6 (section 10.2).
- Occupancy P(n)
- Thermal-equilibrium probability that a vacancy holds n H at a given temperature and H₂ pressure, from consistently referenced electronic energies and ideal-gas H₂ terms, conditional on an existing vacancy; solid vibrations and state multiplicities remain uncomputed (section 10.3).
- Escape path
- A trial route for H to leave a vacancy. Refining one route does not establish the lowest available exit barrier; section 10.4 reports one path through fixed Ni atoms.
- Collective mode
- A pattern of coupled atomic motion with a characteristic frequency. Its frequencies and atomic participation require force-constant calculations; they do not follow from binding energies alone.
- Coherence
- A persistent phase relationship between motions or fields across a specified distance and time. The proposed vacancy-based coherence requires evidence of coupling, spatial correlations and decay times; it is not established by a symmetric structure.